Kills

[legear]

http://csr.wwiionline.com/scripts/services/persona/sortie.jsp?sid=1204668&pid=601141&page=1

Killed mika82, got the game kill credit for it, but for some reason 4g kills are not registering... kill stats always get cut in half for 4gs.... and you already know about the inf not get any credit what so ever...

for some reason, my death always counts against me... is the axis not effected buy this bug...

[uglyboy]

I did not have any of my kills recorded in the last few days, deaths are recorded tho, it's a known issue by now.

[DOC]

the bug doesn't know if you are Axis or Allied

we're still tracking this down, it's in the HOST kill stamp somewhere I think

[legear]

the bug doesn't know if you are Axis or Allied

we're still tracking this down, it's in the HOST kill stamp somewhere I think

just seems certain units are only affected... i know 4gs for sure, havent noticed it with other panzers...

[DOC]

Still it's never wise to make the assumption, for example have you tested every single unit in the game in all 3 countries ? At least 10 times for each ? Otherwise there is doubt, and doubt doubles the workload. We will struggle with the worload even if everyone reduced it ... increasing it only makes it worse.

It's critical to us that there be no doubt before we reach any conclusion, it should be for you too.

[ratatosk]

Still it's never wise to make the assumption, for example have you tested every single unit in the game in all 3 countries ? At least 10 times for each ? Otherwise there is doubt, and doubt doubles the workload. We will struggle with the worload even if everyone reduced it ... increasing it only makes it worse.

It's critical to us that there be no doubt before we reach any conclusion, it should be for you too.

DOC, the problem that I have with replies like this is that you are implying that your QA process "tested every single unit in the game in all 3 countries" when it clearly did not, but you expect customers to pick up the slack. I've done software development for 19 years and read the entire 1.34 episode as a QA failure- I understand how that happens, generally because some suit is yapping about "we're running late, release it and we'll sweep up later!" but that's just to give them long enough to roll out the blamethrower and get it deployed and aimed.

I DO understand not wanting to chase ghosts based on what somebody thought they saw out of the corner of their eye, fair enough. But perhaps you could outline the QA testing template that CRS used so at least people will understand what you consider a reasonable approach? Does it extend beyond the developer telling you it works, you taking a look, and then throwing it out to the Builders to test? If not, then I see the problem, you don't have QA, you have no more than User Acceptance Testing which is always a bust without actual QA.

Thanks.

Edited January 14, 2012 by ratatosk

[GOPHUR]

http://csr.wwiionline.com/scripts/services/persona/sortie.jsp?sid=1204668&pid=601141&page=1

Killed mika82, got the game kill credit for it, but for some reason 4g kills are not registering... kill stats always get cut in half for 4gs.... and you already know about the inf not get any credit what so ever...

for some reason, my death always counts against me... is the axis not effected buy this bug...

Unable to replicate.

Test 1

• p1 spawn sherm76

• p2 spawn pzIVG

• p1 kill p2

• repeat until 3 kills

• p1 despawn

• aar sees 3 kills on pz4g

• csr shows 3 kills on pz4g

http://csr.wwiionline.com/scripts/services/persona/sortie.jsp?sid=1380926&pid=416718

If you're seeing something different I'll need to find a replication method.

[TR6AL]

Just check my account , Almost none of my kills get through to CSR enev though they show up in aar ..

Last night I killed a 232 , a p4 and a rifleman and only 232 showed up in csr .. I am garanteed none of my ei kills will come through .This has been going on with my account for a couple of weeks at least .

[TR6AL]

OK just as a test before i despawn , my aar says I killed a p4g at 15:51 and was killed by Vallekanoo and Im in an M10. Looks like my stats came through but Vespa250's didn't ( the 4g I killed )

[legear]

Unable to replicate.

Test 1

• p1 spawn sherm76

• p2 spawn pzIVG

• p1 kill p2

• repeat until 3 kills

• p1 despawn

• aar sees 3 kills on pz4g

• csr shows 3 kills on pz4g

http://csr.wwiionline.com/scripts/services/persona/sortie.jsp?sid=1380926&pid=416718

it seems to happen if you kill more units like 8or 10.... You will lose csr credit for at least one.... im not assumming anything doc....just trying to give you guys some info to help you fix it...i wanna play...not fix or test

[TR6AL]

With me it makes no difference how many I kill . After one I don't get anything or 3 kills , makes no difference . Last night I didn't get credit for at least 10 kills and also deaths that didn't appear to count .. Most where one kill missions .

[binky]

Stats looking better after server reset Jan 18.

Not a guarantee. Your mileage may vary. Batteries not included.

[GOPHUR]

I'm having trouble testing that with only 3 of them on the list. Let me see what I can do.